| | | | |
| 2012 | Rory Mcllroy | Kiawah Island Golf Resort, Ocean Course | 275 (−13) |
| 2011 | Keegan Bradley | Atlanta Athletic Club | 272 (−8) Playoff |
| 2010 | Martin Kaymer | Whistling Straits Country Club | 277 [-11] Playoff |
| 2009 | Y.E. Yang | Hazeltine National Golf Club | 280 [-8] |
| 2008 | Pádraig Harrington | Oakland Hills Country Club, South Course | 277 [−3] |
| 2007 | Tiger Woods | Southern Hills Country Club | 272 [−8] |
| 2006 | Tiger Woods | Medinah Country Club, Course No. 3 | 270 [−18] |
| 2005 | Phil Mickelson | Baltusrol Golf Club, Lower Course | 276 [−4] |
| 2004 | Vijay Singh | Whistling Straits, Straits Course | 280 [−8] |
| 2003 | Shaun Micheel | Oak Hill Country Club, East Course | 276 [−4] |
| 2002 | Rich Beem | Hazeltine National Golf Club | 278 [−10] |
| 2001 | David Toms | Atlanta Athletic Club, Highlands Course | 265 [−15] |
| 2000 | Tiger Woods | Valhalla Golf Club | 270 [−18] |
| 1999 | Tiger Woods | Medinah Country Club, Course No. 3 | 277 [−11] |
| 1998 | Vijay Singh | Sahalee Country Club | 271 [−9] |
| 1997 | Davis Love III | Winged Foot Golf Club, West Course | 269 [−11] |
| 1996 | Mark Brooks | Valhalla Golf Club | 277 [−11] |
| 1995 | Steve Elkington | Riviera Country Club | 267 [−17] |
| 1994 | Nick Price | Southern Hills Country Club | 269 [−11] |
| 1993 | Paul Azinger | Inverness Club | 272 [−12] |
| 1992 | Nick Price | Bellerive Country Club | 278 [−6] |
| 1991 | John Daly | Crooked Stick Golf Club | 276 [−12] |
| 1990 | Wayne Grady | Shoal Creek Golf and Country Club | 282 [−6] |
| 1989 | Payne Stewart | Kemper Lakes Golf Club | 276 [−12] |
| 1988 | Jeff Sluman | Oak Tree Golf Club | 272 [−12] |
| 1987 | Larry Nelson | PGA National Resort & Spa | 287 [−1] |
| 1986 | Bob Tway | Inverness Club | 276 [−8] |
| 1985 | Hubert Green | Cherry Hills Country Club | 278 [−10] |
| 1984 | Lee Trevino | Shoal Creek Golf and Country Club | 273 [−15] |
| 1983 | Hal Sutton | Riviera Country Club | 274 [−10] |
| 1982 | Raymond Floyd | Southern Hills Country Club | 272 [−8] |
| 1981 | Larry Nelson | Atlanta Athletic Club, Highlands Course | 273 [−7] |
| 1980 | Jack Nicklaus | Oak Hill Country Club, East Course | 274 [−6] |
| 1979 | David Graham | Oakland Hills Country Club, South Course | 272 [−8] |
| 1978 | John Mahaffey | Oakmont Country Club | 276 [−8] |
| 1977 | Lanny Wadkins | Pebble Beach Golf Links | 282 [−6] |
| 1976 | Dave Stockton | Congressional Country Club, Blue Course | 281 [+1] |
| 1975 | Jack Nicklaus | Firestone Country Club, South Course | 276 [−4] |
| 1974 | Lee Trevino | Tanglewood Park, Championship Course | 276 [−4] |
| 1973 | Jack Nicklaus | Canterbury Golf Club | 277 [−7] |
| 1972 | Gary Player | Oakland Hills Country Club, South Course | 281 [+1] |
| 1971 | Jack Nicklaus | PGA National Golf Club | 281 [−7] |
| 1970 | Dave Stockton | Southern Hills Country Club | 279 [−1] |
| 1969 | Raymond Floyd | NCR Country Club, South Course | 276 [−8] |
| 1968 | Julius Boros | Pecan Valley Golf Club | 281 [+1] |
| 1967 | Don January | Columbine Country Club | 281 [−7] |
| 1966 | Al Geiberger | Firestone Country Club, South Course | 280 [E] |
| 1965 | Dave Marr | Laurel Valley Golf Club | 280 [−4] |
| 1964 | Bobby Nichols | Columbus Country Club | 271 [−9] |
| 1963 | Jack Nicklaus | Dallas Athletic Club, Blue Course | 279 [−5] |
| 1962 | Gary Player | Aronimink Golf Club | 278 [−2] |
| 1961 | Jerry Barber | Olympia Fields Country Club | 277 [−3] |
| 1960 | Jay Hebert | Firestone Country Club, South Course | 281 [+1] |
| 1959 | Bob Rosburg | Minneapolis Golf Club | 277 [−3] |
| 1958 | Dow Finsterwald | Llanerch Country Club | 276 [−4] |